Have been here a billion times. I love Reuben's mainly for location, service and reliability of what you get. The portions are huge but the prices are a bit inflated. The smoked meat I think has gotten a bit better over the years. Has to be a fatty cut for it to be good imo. The coleslaw is lacking. Others have had the poutine, which is among the weaker choices in Montreal (McCain fries with admittedly good curds). Location is perfect for tourists (Peel and Ste-Catherine). Staff is friendly, kind and helpful. A solid 4/5 in my books.
If you own or manage Reuben's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.