The service left a lot to be desired- I think the guy said as little as he possibly could. The Christmas decorations were way over the top, it felt like sitting inside of a neon sign (it was much too bright for my taste). Wine selection by the glass is very limited. We ordered the Canelloni which came out incredibly runny, my friend ate it with a spoon. I had the seafood platter. The cod and scallops were good, but the potato and veg were very undercooked. My knife had a hard time getting through the broccoli.
Overall, I would not go back. Food and service were bad and the prices are high.
If you own or manage Papa's Pier 17, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.