This is a good restaurant, and very rarely have I had a bad meal here. However equally very rarely have I had an exceptional meal, or even a great meal. The prices have been going steadily up over the years, and while whistler is never going to be a cheap place to eat, rim rock is comfortably up there with the most expensive in town. It also no longer feels as relaxed to me as it once did, maybe that's just personal bias.
The long and short of it, this is a solid restaurant and if you are looking for a place to eat out tonight I doubt you will regret this choice. However is it the best in town, for me the answer is no. Would it be in my whistler top 10, yes for sure, would it be in my top 5, maybe not.
If you own or manage Rim Rock Cafe & Oyster Bar, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.