We picked the Water Street Cafe based on the recommendations of Trip Advisor, and we weren't disappointed. The location is central, very close to our hotel; a very nicely decorated room reminiscent of European cafes. The menu is heavily accented on Italian fare, and has a good variety of choices (although not extensive). There's something for everyone, IMHO.
We had a wonderful bottle of Sandhill Osprey Ridge Vineyard Viognier, which I heartily recommend. The crab cake appetizer was the best we've had in a couple of years. The main courses were smoked salmon risotto, the spinach risotto and the chicken -- all were nicely prepared, well presented and very tasty.
The cafe looks onto the steam clock, which is a nice bonus. All in all, a very pleasant evening!