My wife and I attended a play about 4 years ago and promptly signed up as season ticket holders. We've been going ever since. The product is good, and what's more it's consistent. Occasionally they do things that stretch the limits of "mystery" but we've never seen anything that we'd classify as "bad". Occasionally they do something that's outstanding.
In contrast we got season tickets to Theatre Calgary last year. Their product was incosistent, and what's more it ranged from terrible to mediocre. When renewal season came we quickly renewed Vertigo, cancelled Theatre Calgary, and gave some of the money we'd saved to Vertigo in the form of a donation. I think that says it all.
If you own or manage Vertigo Mystery Theatre, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.