I booked this hotel based purely on price, and it having had some OK reviews. Last time I went to CSL, I stayed at the Finisterra which, including airfare, was ~$950- for 5 nights. I wanted to stay twice as long this time, so for 10 nights incl. airfare, expedia's package with this hotel was ~$1150-. An extra $200- for twice as long; seemed a perfect fit.
The only reason I give an overall "neutral" rating as opposed to a higher rating is due to the location, and the fact that it's somewhat noisy (more on this later); otherwise it's perfectly fine.
This place has been around for a while, but about a year ago it was bought by Best Western and extensively refurbished. It's pretty much still in near-new condition all-around, and the staff are always at work keeping it clean and tidy.
As far as location goes, I felt like the info on the hotel's info pages was a bit misleading. It's farthur from Playa Medano, and Centro CSL, than the impression I had gotten. It's a somewhat lengthy walk to the beginning of central CSL (ie: Puerto Paraiso mall), down a hot, dusty and uneven sidewalk. I'd say approx. 10 blocks.
To Playa Medano, it's a bit closer, but looking at a map it seems closer still - probably because there are fewer cross-streets so it "seems" like 3 or 4 blocks but it's more like 8.
If you are not prepared to take a long hot walk each day to, and from, town, then you're relegated to renting a car (which, at this hotel, would be easy - plenty of free parking and the lot is patrolled by security), or taking a taxi to/from town (about $6- each way), or hopping one of the local busses (60 cents).
Most days I walked to/from my destinations, but I did take a taxi back 3 or 4 times - too much sun, walking, beer, food; I just wasn't up for it all the time. Especially when I first arrived and had not yet acclimated myself to the heat (~95f) and humidity (~75%). I admit to thinking about checking out after the first couple days, into a place closer in town, but figured I'd make the best of it and see how things played out. By the end of my stay (10 days), it wasn't so bad afterall.
The hotel is situated across the street from the bullfight ring, about as far out as you can get before you're almost in the corridor. On the way into CSL, the "Welcome to Cabo San Lucas" sign is right by the hotel, so that gives you an idea that even the locals consider this hotel to be on the "edge" of town.
It's the location that makes this place more affordable, however.
There is still a trash-strewn empty lot next door, but with all the construction going on in CSL, it probably won't be that way forever. There is also a large, trash-strewn empty lot across the street where it seems construction was started, but halted, some time ago (tend to see a fair number of these aborted projects all around the area).
The location is probably very good for someone who will rent a car and wants to be based in CSL but doesn't necessarily need to be in the center, and for those who don't require a full-service hotel or any amenities on-site.
As for the hotel itself, there are two, 2-story wings with ample parking in the center. The pool is clean, kept at a good temperature, though a bit small-ish, with about 1/3 of the pool taken up with a shallow end (ie: where you can place your lounge chair in the water). It is indeed shaded for part of the day by the hotel buildings themselves.
Security seems tight - always one or two security people around, manning the parking lot gate and/or just making the rounds.
The room was average-sized and about what I had expected. Two double beds, dinette with seating for 4, spacious closet (for my needs), small bathroom (probably due to the large tub/shower combo), TV with ~65 satellite channels of mostly Spanish-language programming (though they do carry CNN Worldwide and BBC in English, and a lot of programs are sub-titled so there's always something to watch, if you feel the need). The kitchenette was a nice touch, with mini-fridge, two cooktops, sink, coffee maker and free coffee, and enough plates & flatware for 4 persons. Two pans and a few other accessories - you won't be whipping up a 4-course meal here but certainly enough to get by.
Two free bottles of water everyday; at some point they began leaving three bottles - one extra by the coffee maker, presumably so you could use it, instead of tap water, to make your brew.
No shared internet (I thought I'd read someplace it was available in the lobby), but the front desk staff says it's available in all the rooms if you have a laptop (there were plenty of electrical outlets and a CAT5 jack).
There was always a good amount of water on the floor after a shower - I couldn't find the source and no amount of making sure the shower door remained closed would remedy it - presumably there was a leak in the seal between the enclosure and tile surrounds, or maybe it was coming up through the floor drain; nonetheless it was always puddled in the bathroom and running out into the rest of the room. Not sure why they haven't fixed this, as it's a pretty obvious problem. Room 309, in case you want to avoid it.
The only real issue was the noise... There can't have been any insulation whatsoever between the rooms. Having tile floors, I could quite clearly hear every footstep of my upstairs neighbors, as well as when they would drag the wooden chairs around. I could also clearly hear TV sets and people talking, above and to the side. Not shouting - talking in a normal tone of voice, and yet I could hear them.
In addition, the hotel staff starts cleaning around 8am, wet-sweeping the tiled hallway outside, dragging the maid carts around, and yelling at each other across the parking lot from building to building. If you want to sleep in, unless you're in a zonk-out from drinking the night before, the daily activity will wake you up as soon as it gets close to your room (for me, it was typically 8am).
Occasionally one can hear street traffic as well, especially the semi-trucks that like to use their engine brakes (that loud "braaaaap!" noise you sometimes hear them make) at the large intersection next door.
I liked the in-room safe, but wish they had the kind where you program your own code, instead of having a key; thus the need to carry a key with you everyplace, instead of a number in your head.
I never used to avail myself of free continental breakfasts, but here it's almost necessary, since other food options are limited. There is a mini-mart on-site, with a pretty limited selection of foodstuffs, but plenty by way of beer/soda/etc to drink. In any event, the breakfast is available 7am to 11am (though I think 7.30 is more likely when they're stocking it), and features a variety of fruits, baked goods, juices, spreads (for bread/toast), coffee and tea. I'm a convert - it's a good way to get something in you before making the long trek into town.
The hotel was pretty empty my entire stay; the first few days seemed like there were more people working than staying there, as they do seemingly have a large staff of maids, maintenence workers, security folks, and other employees. The clientele during my stay seemingly consisted of an equal number of foreign tourists and Mexicans on holiday.
Getting there:
I hadn't made plans for getting from the SJD airport to the hotel - figured I'd wing it. Ended up taking the SuburCabos/Los Cabos Express bus for $13-. This bus departs twice a day, I am told, and you don't need a reservation (unless you happen to arrive when a throng of others do). They will stop at pretty much any hotel or location on the way to, or in, CSL, for the $13- flat-rate.
Look for the bus itself, as well as someone in a yellow shirt - you might get lucky and have Alejandro as your host. On the way to town, the bus stops at Ultramarinos El Mono, so you can stock up on cold beer, soda, water and whatnot. I'm guessing Alejandro gets a kick-back from this, but maybe not. You'll also get the run-down of various events happening during your stay, as well as ideas for things to do. The bus company is apparently now owned by the Marriott hotel chain, and you'll also get a short and no-pressure pitch to tour the new Westin Regina, which by all accounts is a pretty top-end place to stay. If you take them up on their offer for the free breakfast and tour, you'll get a voucher for some free activity, ie: snorkeling trip, booze cruise, ATV excursion, or a number of other things to choose from.
Of course, there are other busses, shuttles, taxis, rental cars etc; it's no problem.
Getting around:
Lots of walking, unless you rent a car or take taxis/busses. To central CSL, just start walking down the main drag and soon enough you'll be at the marina. To get to Playa Medano, start in the same direction, but cross the street and take a left at the signs for City Club/Playa Pescado. Down a dirt road, over a hill, and it appears in front of you.
If you want to spend a day in San Jose del Cabo, the regular bus runs about every 15 minutes, most of which have AC, and costs approx. $2- each way. They run 5am to 11pm, though I wouldn't risk missing the last one, in which case you'll pay about $35 or $40 for a taxi back to CSL.
In CSL, you can negotiate for a short trip via BiciTaxi (bicycle-powered taxi with room for up to 4 passengers). Pretty much only see these guys on the main drag...
Getting back to SJD airport:
The front desk can arrange a shuttle for $17- per person; this turned out to be just a standard taxi-van. So on a good run, the driver will have made out pretty well, but if there are only a few people (there were 3, including me, on my trip), he's only doing about as well as with one passenger. The shuttle leaves at 9.30am, 11.30am, 1.30pm...probably other times as well. It was direct - they didn't stop at any other hotels to pick up passengers, so the trip back was the expected approx. 45 minutes.
I'll likely write up a more overall experience of this trip, at a later date. Hope this info is of help to someone.