My DH and I (early 30s) just returned from a 5-night stay at the Sheraton. I have mixed feelings regarding our stay, so I'll try my best to detail it out.
The pros....
The reviews are true - it's a gorgeous property! My DH, a former golf course superintendent, is very observant when it comes to landscaping. He was quite impressed. The groundkeepers were meticulous and obviously took pride in their work. The architects did a fine job in marrying the dessert landscape with greenery and the lushness of tropical plants.
The hotel is also beautiful from the courtyards to the villas to the pools. We had a great time staying in the main building - room 2001 (ocean view). It was very easy to go from room to restaurant to pool back to room. I can see how some of those who stay out in the outward villas would get tired of walking, but at least you have lots of pretty things to look at.
There are some amazing balconies at the Sheraton. While ours was decent (ocean view from the side), friends of ours stayed in an ocean front and were lucky enough to have a room directly above Tomatoes. Wow - it spanned both the side of the room and front, making it bigger than the room itself! If you get the chance, request that one. You won't be disappointed.
The ocean is dangerous. While we were there, two people got flipped and one sprained her ankle. So if you want to play in the water, this is not the resort for you. But if you don't mind hanging out in that breathtaking infinity edge pool of theirs, it more than makes up for it.
Overall, I would say the service was quite good. While no one went out of their way to please us (except the maid service, more on that in a minute), we never had to wait long for anything. The bartenders at all bars were pleasant, spoke English and humored our poor Spanish.
If you prefer to swim with your drinks, the main pool has servers to accommodate. Just flag one down with the cold towel they give you to cool off. :)
The servers at the restaurants were nice and always available. The maid service was pretty good. We got towel animals and double cleaning each day. After we spent the day swimming, we'd come up to take a nap and get ready for the evening, and while we were at dinner, they'd clean up again. Very nice!
Speaking of dinner, this brings me to my first con...
The resort charges a preminum for everything. Water is close to $8, liquor drinks usually a tad more. Beer is $5.50 - a relative deal! If you are a big drinker, be sure you get the schedule for the rotating Happy Hour. 2-4-1 all day long - depending on the bar.
Food was by far the most ridiculously overpriced. We had the buffet a few times. Breakfast was $25pp, dinner $29 (and that was one of the cheaper nights!). The breakfast was barely more than what you would get at a Mariott free continental breakfast, albeit in a much prettier setting. Dinner was tasty (it was Latin Flavors night), but instead of using chicken breasts in the dish, they used the much cheaper wings. If the dish calls for wings, by all means use it. We've been known to belly up to an all-you-can-eat-wing place once or twice, but I don't like paying $30 for it.
Each morning they served free coffee outside the Tomatoes restaurant, but I would have preferred they have a small counter service location where I could buy bagels, tea and the like. Sometimes I want a simple breakfast and not pay a fortune for it. Being that the resort is so secluded, I guess they think you have no choice. And unless you rent a car to hit the grocery store, it's true.
If you are looking to stay close to Cabo, this is not the resort for you. While it was never more than a 10-ish minute drive into town, the cabbies charge a premium for their services. You can expect to spend at least $20 each way (for 2 people). There is a shuttle from the Sheraton to the mall, but if you go when it's hot, you will be sweating as soon as you get out of the car. Does not make for a romantic evening if you arrive soaking wet to the restaurant.
(By the way, do not tip the cab drivers. They have a strong union and are doing quite well for themselves.)
On to restaurant reviews - we ate at Tomatoes for breakfast and dinner. Barring any issues I have with cost, I can say I enjoyed all the meals I had there.
We had sushi downstairs at the sports bar which was quite good. There were supposed to have bar food, but when asked for a menu they didn't have one. Not sure why.
We ran over to the Vacation Club side once for breakfast at Girasoles. Really nice location - it's high atop the VC lobby. As an added plus, the meals were more reasonably priced.
Our favorite place to dine was the poolside bar - Sirenes. Every meal there was yummy - chicken fingers, quesadillas, BBQ sandwich, tuna wrap. All perfectly hit the spot.
And of course I have to tell you about our absolute favorite place to hang out on property - the swim up bar! If you go from 4-5, it's Happy Hour with 2-4-1 drinks. I can never drink 2 pina coladas (besides that would be like 900 calories), so I ask for one and to double up on the liquor.
It is a nice resort and overall I was impressed with the locale, grounds and service. Would I return? Probably not - only because it was such a chore to go into town, I'd rather stay closer and experience Cabo more. But if you are looking for a relaxing vacation and don't mind the price, it's a great choice.