Based on the relatively high ranking on Trip Advisor, I booked this hotel for a recent stay. Our time there was a mixed bag. Allow me to elaborate.
PRO: We arrived early, around noon, and they let us check in immediately. The manager and his wife (?) were very friendly. A boy (manager's son?) carried our bags to the room. We later met the owner, Alex, and everyone seemed to be very nice and helpful, even helping to book some tours while we were there. The best part of the hotel are the people who run it.
CON: I had been informed that there was construction earlier in the year; however, we arrived to find that there was major rennovation going on presently to the front of the building. Workers were there by 8am every morning, making noise. Because of the construction, the promised Internet was not available, so we had to walk about 3-4 blocks each day just to check email.
PRO: The hotel is centrally located, within walking distance of many of the major tourist spots, restaurants, the harbor, etc.
CON: However, it is a considerable walk to the beach. It takes a solid 20 minutes even if you know exactly where you are going. On our first trip, we did not know all of the little twists, turns, and shortcuts to take, so it took nearly an hours navigating through the hot and often dirty streets.
PRO: The room was a decent size, including small bedroom, kitchenette, sitting area, and small bathroom.
CON: The place did not feel clean at all. The first thing I noticed was that someone had left fingernail and toenail clippings on the endtable next to the bed, and the maid had somehow not seen them for cleaning. This undermined my confidence about how well the less noticible things were cleaned, so we didn't even used the maid service the whole time we were there. The kitchenette included some plates and sliverware, but I question how thoroughly they were cleaned. Moreover, the room was hot, even with the A/C. The A/C was in the bedroom area, so it was practically useless for the kitchen or sitting area, and it took nearly a full day for the room to cool down enough to be comfortable. The wall unit was so loud that it made sleeping difficult, but at least it did drown out all the city noise (including, inexplicably) the sound of roosters crowing at all times of the day and night.
PRO: There was a TV with cable and a refrigerator.
CON: Out of several dozen TV channels, only 2 or 3 were in English (BBC News, CNN, possibly one other). The frige was nearly worthless. The temperature contol knob was broken off and could not be turned at all, rusted in place. The refrigerator itself was not cold at all, just barely above room temperature. The small freezer section did work, though barely. So, when we wanted to keep something cold (meat, for example), we had to put it in the freezer, which did eventually make it frozen after a day or two.
PRO: A very good Italian restaurant, Salvatore's, was adjoining the hotel, so it made for a very convenient dinner, and it made the hotel smell nice in the evenings.
CON: Because of restaurant, the hotel's pool, which was located right in the middle of it, was neither large nor private. The pool was so tiny and shallow that it wasn't worth mentioning in the hotel's promo. And, if you get in the pool, you are literally 2 feet away from the tables in the restaurant. Consequently, the pool is just wasted space; they would be better off just adding space to the restaurant. I noticed that not a single hotel guest used the pool the whole time we were there.
One more point: outside the main office is a refrigerator where they keep a variety of cold bottled beverages (mainly water and Coke). I would recommend buying drinks here each day before leaving the hotel because they are some of the cheapest in the city (especially if you buy the larger sizes; e.g., a 1 gallon bottle of water is $2; and the 1.5 liter bottle of water or Coke is $1.50). If you are going for a long, hot walk through the city, the 1.5 liter bottle can be a lifesaver, and it is much cheaper than in most stores frequented by tourists, which often charge the same price for a bottle one-third the size.
All in all, Siesta Suites is one of the cheapest hotel options in Cabo. We got our rooms for only about $75 per night. Of course, in this case, you tend to get what you pay for. If you are on a tight budget and don't care about the noise, lack of cleanliness, lack of a pool, and long walk to the beach, at least you are close to some good restaurants and are in the heart of the city. All in all, I would rate it around a 2.5. Since I can't leave a rating with a half-point, though, I'm going to round down to 2 since it appears many others have tended to round up.