I'm Italian myself and I was there with other 2 Italian friends.
in the first place we were a bit skeptics, since it was a tourist guide sending us there; but after we seat and we tasted out meal -seafood spaghetti (spaghetti allo scoglio)- we definitely changed our mind!
the food was great, the staff was really nice and the atmosphere was excellent, we were 50 meters away from the sea.
For our last night in Playa, we went back there, we had an Argentinian beef steak with fresh grilled vegetable...just delicious.
we were so much in love with the place that we went back there for a quick espresso also the same day of our departure! lol
if you pass by, definitely stop there it is worth it.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.