Never thought ourselves much as "beach club" types but access to Indigo was included in our stay at Maya Villa, so we thought we'd give it a shot. Sure glad we did! The loungers/umbrellas/towel service were divine, making days at the beach so easy. No need to bring bag after bag of supplies to the beach. Just throw a few books in a bag, hop over, and let the folks at Indigo take care of you. Service was impeccable and the views excellent. This part of the beach is used by a lot of the fishing/scuba diving boats in the area to dock, but we didn't mind it at all - it was scenic and if you really want an open stretch of beach, it's readily available just a few minute walk down the sand.
Prices weren't cheap, but they weren't unreasonable either. I'm sure you can get cheaper at other beach clubs, but it's probably going to be at the cost of the comfort, quality of service, not to mention quality of food/drink you get at Indigo.
Overall, give Indigo a shot! And if you happen to be staying at El Taj, Maya Villa or Porto Playa and have access included in your stay, don't miss your chance to enjoy the wonderful spot!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.