We were going to skip this place because of the reviews on here, but we decided to try it after loving Cafe Pop (same owner) so much.
This place could not have been as bad as Pop is good. The fish dishes we had were bland and not well-prepared to boot. The two fish dishes we ordered ended up being flavorless plates of food. It just wasn't worth an evening of our vacation. If you care about fine dining, this place should not even be on your radar. If you like local dishes expertly cooked with good ingredients, even if you are not too picky about some minor misfires here and there, this place will be a huge disappointment.
The setting is cute, and with the right dishes, ingredients, and preparation, would have been a romantic evening.
If you own or manage Portico del Peregrino, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.