I recently sampled several top rated restaurants on Isla Mujeras. My absolute favorite dinner of fresh caught Black Grouper (pecan encrusted with a nice tangy sauce) veggies done just right and a nice Chardonnay to top it off, was consumed at Asia Caribe. I also enjoyed the street side dining on Hidalgo and conversation with Peter and his wife. It's nice to have the personal touch at dinner. I went back the second time (my only repeat during our stay. I can't imagine why this restaurant isn't among the top rated on Trip Advisor. I can see where some would go for environment (Mango Cafe for a more village location or Olivia (a little more romantic) but if you like well-prepared food, AC should have top billing.
If you own or manage Asia Caribe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.