On the last night of our vacation, my wife and agreed that, while waiting for dinner on the beautfiul Cozumel coastline, we were actually looking forward to returning to our cold hometown. The Aura offerred great promise, but our experience fell unbelievably flat.
To be fair, I will say that the hotel itself was truly remarkable. It looks like it just opened yesterday, with beautiful rooms, a great open-air lobby, and spacious pools. Our food, once we were served, was excellent. The room service was fast and the food was great.
But a hotel cannot expect to be judged solely by its appearance and the taste of its food. Food has to be served, rooms have to be cleaned, drinks have to be served - and to be honest, all of those on the service end seemed like either they didn't care or had no idea what they were doing. It appears that they are greatly understaffed and don't have time to offer the best possible service.
Our first meal after checking in was at the outdoor restaurant, Hava Grill. My wife and I waited, literally, an hour for a cheeseburger and a chicken sandwich. We chalked that up to an anomoly in what we perceived as an excellent resort for food. We later discovered that the waitstaff at this restaurant also waited on poolside patrons at the same time they were serving lunch at the restaurant. It wasn't that they didn't work hard, but you can't be everywhere at once.
Our first dinner that night was at the Isola restaurant, which is half inside and half outside. I think the concept of this restaurant underscores exactly what is wrong with this hotel. It's a beautiful restaurant that looked just like the website picture, but it has a buffet 5 nights a week. If buffets are your thing, fine, but in my opinion, a luxury hotel offers sit-down service. Not to mention that the buffet was out of half of the items and we had to settle for old pasta with marinara. One of the nights that they did offer a set menu, we had to wait for a table, along with 5 other couples, even though the restaurant was only a third full. While we waited, I asked for two glasses of wine at the bar. I was told that they were out of all white wine. I walked over to the bar at the nearside Hava Grill and was promptly served 2 glasses of wine in 2 soda glasses. Again the food was great, but it takes about 45 minutes for the service, and while you wait, no one stops by to refill your water or wine.
The website describe the hotel as "An all-inclusive adult couples only resort". We saw about 4 or 5 families at the Aura with kids, ranging from middle school to high school. I asked the front desk about this, and they told me that these were families bumped over from the adjacent Sabor and that in Mexico adults are over 13. They also said it's going to 18 and over in May, but I wouldn't believe that. There are two hot tubs at the top-floor Brisas bar, and while we were up there to watch the sunset one night, one was full; the other was full of kids.
The rooms generally were clean. One night we got back from to our room at 5:30pm and it wasn't cleaned. I called the front desk to ask for it to be cleaned. At 8:30, I walked to the front desk and asked again for it to be cleaned. I was told that they were going to clean it right away and was given several towels so my wife and I could at least shower before dinner. After they cleaned the room and we showered, we finally arrived at the Hava Grill at 9:45pm. We were told that the restaurant closed in 15 minutes and we were denied service. That led us to the only other option, a night at the Isola buffet. On a separate note, the floor in our room clearly wasn't cleaned, because we had a swarm of ants in the room on our last night.
If you do decide to stay at the Aura, my one piece of advice would be to hoard as many water bottles as you possibly can. They say it's "All-Inclusive", but they won't give you water bottles at any of the restaurants or bars. The mini-bar in the room is stocked with 2-3 bottles for an entire day and you cannot ask for more; not to mention that ours wasn't re-stocked on 3 of the days. My wife and I both got sick for 2 days, and I don't know it was from the lack of water, bad water, or bad food.
I completely understand if this review sounds like it's coming from a snubby, up-tight traveler. But I can promise that my wife and I have never complained about a hotel before. The thing you have to consider is that many of the positive comments we heard we from those upgraded from the Sabor side. Once the hotel actually starts to fill up with those that actually book the Aura with the regular rates, the hotel is in for a rude awakening. There are about 100 luxury resorts throught Cozumel and Riviera Maya that all cost around that same price, and this particular hotel is not worth the price of admission, at least not yet.