My husband and I stayed at Hotel Cozumel from 6/25-6/29. All in all, we were satisfied with our stay, although it was nothing fancy.
After reading some of the reviews on the rooms, here is my rebuttle. The rooms are adequate (I'd equate them with a Comfort Inn). There can be a musty smell at times as it is VERY humid at this time of year. The air conditioning works EXTREMELY well...keep it cool, it will cut down on the mildew. We tried to hang much of our wet gear out on the patio (another good feature), however, if it rains for more than a few hours, we found our articles never got completely dry as it was just too humid. (Next time I may buy some "stop the stink" at the dive shop). Our bathroom left a little to be desired as there was a tiny bit of mold growing in the ceiling...but nothing that freaked us out. For the reviewer who wrote about the rain pouring into the rooms on the ground floor, I believe she was mistaken...it rained all day and we never saw any rooms leaking...what we did see was that every few days they POWERWASH the tile floors in the halls and they block the doors with towels to prevent leaking, but it was quite wet when they did this...but hey, at least they are concerned about cleanliness. In general, do be careful in the halls as they are not air conditioned and the walls sweat because of the AC in the rooms...makes it a little slippery if you have flip flops on. But we saw no "flood problems."
Food was adequate...I certainly did not gorge myself, but received an adequate meal each time. We did go into town most nights for dinner. Eating just breakfast and lunch at the hotel paid for the "all inclusive" option...it's definetely worth it.
The location was a better point if you desire to go into town...it's about a 10-15 minute walk. We recommend going to the "Misson" for dinner...one block south of the main square...steak and seafood primarily. Excellent red snapper. There is also a great deal of shopping to be done downtown. The only drawback of the location was that it was quite far from most of the divesites. The better dive sites took us an hour to an hour and fifteen minutes. However, it is closer than Scuba Club, Cozumel Palace and Casa Mexicana...to name a few.
Now the dive shop. I know there is one particular reviewer who keeps stating that the onsite dive operator, Dive Paradise, is "unsafe" and that they "left her in the water" during a night dive. While I can't comment on her particular circumstances, I can state that I felt very safe during our dives, and yes, we did do a night dive and, no, we were not left in the water. What I will say, however, is that it is very intimidating to do the night dive as there were many dive operators that followed us out there and we found ourselves getting close to many groups and I feared I would follow the wrong group...but everyone was OK. We were in groups of 5-6 which made it easier. (In all, I didn't care for the night dive...the diving there is so good that the day dives are just as good). If you do have to abort the dive early, they give you the "sausage" and are instructed in how to signal the boat with your light if you don't want to follow the group on the surface. In all, we made nine dives....yes, they have slow, fast, and faster boats. The faster boats are limited to 6 divers, but you will pay more for diving on those boats. Almost everyone does the standard boats and they will alternate you between the "slow" and the "fast" boats. They will bring up to 16 divers onboard, but we were split into small groups for our dives. Try to go as far south as you can when on the faster boats...deep palancar, etc as these are the better dives. The dive masters always went through the dive plan and safety rules. There is one divemaster who will want you to always stay 4 or 5 feet above him if you do not dive with a computer (which I don't) so I'd say they went a little overboard with that. But overall, I was very happy with the operation. We met one group of dive instructors who state that for the past 18 or so years, they bring a group of divers down four times a year to do their certification dives and that they prefer Dive Paradise above the rest. So, if I can get a recommendation from those folks, I'd say take it!
All in all, this was a great value we booked through an agent who specializes in dive travel. I would classify this as a "dive hotel" without anything extraordinary. If you are in Cozumel primarily to dive, I would definetely recommend this hotel and Dive Paradise. If you want to be close to the "action" I would definetely stay at a downtown hotel or something on the Northern Side. If you want something elaborate and "higher class" or want to be really close to the dive sites, I would stay much further South on the island. If I was not there to dive, I would've been quite disappointed. So, happy diving!






