I just got back from staying at the Allegro in cozumel on july 2nd. Our group stayed there for 3 nights. Make no mistake about it, but if you get stuck with a room in the front by the lobby your going to be smelling the sewage plant the whole time. its not that bad but its defniitely noticeable. All in all the hotel is situated on a very nice beach and the grounds are immaculate. They are still in the process of planting new palm trees and other plants after the beating the hotel took after last summers hurricane. Nonetheless the place looks wonderful. However i do have some complaints. The first one being the beer selection is not what i anticipated at all, if you dont like corona this is not the place for you to stay, in fact if you dont like draft corona then your in for a rude awakening. All the hotel had was draft corona. That wasnt that big of a deal but i have travelled to almost all the other resort destinations in mexico and have never been forced to drink only one type of beer. Moving on, the other types of mixed drinks you get are watered down to say the least. However if going there tip "Maria" she is the pool waitress and your drinks will contain more than enough alcohol. One thing that disappointed us was that there was no drink menu, so if you dont normally drink "fruity" types of drinks then you may be at a loss as far as what to get. Let me let you in on a little secret, ask for the bananna mama, its the best drink they have. It looks like pepto bismol but you wont be disappointed I promise. They begin to fill you up after a while but after being in the hot sun all day these are quite refreshing indeed.
Now for the food, the food was so so. The best meal i had was a blt (bacon lettuce tomato) poolside and i would highly recommend this to anyone going to be staying at the allegro. The hamburgers were ok too but this was all lunch food. Breakfast was by far the best meal of the day, the french toast is delicious, the omelettes are made to your specifications and the pancakes are pretty good too. Dinner was ok at best, i dont think there was one meal i had there that was really any good. I never ate at either of the restraunts that required reservations but one couple in our group did (they ate at the mexcian one) and they said it was horrible. Actually we went to town one night and ate at le mission and it was the best lobster i have ever had and the service was outstanding, i highly recommend this if anyone plans on going into cozumel for a night on the town. Oh and as far as the requirement that you need to be dressed up to eat at the restraunts is bs. I saw plenty of people in shorts and flip flops at those places, so dont stress over taking nice clothes just to wear to dinner one night. I mean guys, a nice polo and pressed shorts is fine' dont worry about taking slacks. I was told by the hotel concierge that they would not let you into these places without proper attire but that was a load of bs.
The pool was awesome and they have some fun games that go on during the day like bingo and pool volleyball, both of which we participated in and had a blast. The beach is awesome the water is so crystal clear and you can snorkel right in front of the hotel and "Maria" will come out to the water and wait on you. She is not fluent in english so it helps to know a little spanish when speaking to her.
The rooms were small, but nice, other than the sewer smell and the fact that when the people above me took a shower they're water ran into my bathtub i dont have any complaints (the beds are real firm too). The AC definitely works so dont worry about sweating down there, also tip the maids well and you will get some really cool towel characters designed for you and special sheets and towels as well and extra bottled water. I received a really cool iguana and and a bow tie both of the nights i was there.
All in all i would give the place a 7, the service is good, lots of english speaking staff, but the food and drink was not what i anticipated. The grounds were well kept and the rooms are nice and i would definitely stay there again. I hope this helps other people out there who maybe contemplating a stay there. Oh one last thing Mr sanchos beach bar is about a 600 yard walk down the beach from the allegro so if you dont like the allegro drink selections definitely go give this place a try, you wont be disappointed. Oh but take a cab as the beach sand is so soft that it wears you out walking down there.
Happy travels