I recently went with Valentine's on two separate outings: a snorkeling trip and scuba diving trip. Both were professionally run. The locations were well selected. The trip leaders handled experts and novices very well. I would use Valentine's again. George, one of the owners, takes customer service very seriously. It appears that some negative reviews are from the period before he and his partner took over.
If you own or manage Valentine's Dive Center, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.