Andrew and Smiley were our guides. While Smiley was extremely quiet, Andrew could use a lesson in customer service. He was on his cell phone most of the time. The tour felt more like a LONG water taxi ride. We did see the islands owned by the rich and famous (from far way) and the tour operator wasn't at all enthusiastic about taking us to any of the major attractions like the "Thunderball Grotto," & swimming with the pigs. When we did stop at the grotto and other attractions on the brochure, we were rushed by Andrew, because he said he had to get things ready for the arrival of Tim McGraw, since his family was arriving for Thanksgiving and Andrew was giving them a ride to their island. They advertise a visit to a sandbar, but we were told it wasn't possible for us. A big let down as we were really looking forward to that part of the tour. There was no such thing as a bathroom on the boat, so you better hold it for as long as you can. They only serve water and soda's..no beer and no snacks for a full day tour (in our case it only lasted half a day, but we were asked to pay the full price). For one hundred and sixty per person the day trip was a waste. Our lunch stop was at Staniel Cay Yacht Club, where they served over-priced fried fish and chicken sandwiches. Towards the end of our tour, Andrew cancelled our taxi ride back to the resort and didn't inform Smiley. So 4 of us were almost left stranded thanks to their lack of communication. Thanks to Smiley for giving us a ride back to the resort. Avoid 4C's and instead book something a bit more personal with Coastline or try one of the other outfits on the island.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.