We tried Santana's, Chat n chill, and Big D's. We found that Santana's, much beloved in these parts, is kind of overrated - it's a charming place, with a nice beach location, but given how far away it is, the food is heavily fried and not memorable. Pet peeve - this is the sort of value for money calculation that Trip Advisor reviews often get wrong. If you want lobster, pay $36 or similar in the better restaurant near where you are staying, and get something prepared well - it doesn't make sense to drive a long distance to get one that is only OK for $22. Chat n Chill was fine, but nothing special.
The real revelation is Big D's in Steventon - the conch salad is fantastic , as is the scorched conch (not what you think it is!) and really, so is everything else they do. Big D's is not Bahamian fast food, like Santana's or Chat n chill - it is quality, well prepared, healthy food, all local catch, served in an authentic place, at a good price.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.