Have travelled to Eleuthera on several occasions, and stayed at the Buccaneer twice. Upon arrival, you need to check in at the restaurant (open from 7am till 3pm), one of the few places where you will get breakfast in town. The great thing about this place is the secluded pool. It's a converted farmhouse on a hill a stone's throw from the bay. It has TV, it's relatively clean, and probably has one of the best views of any accommodation in town. You are likely to have the pool to yourself and apart from Laughing Bird Apartments, my favorite place, though Laughing Bird's selling point is their personable owners and the fact that you have cooking facilities. Typically at the Buccaneer there aren't any staff after 3pm till 7 in the morning.