Gaulding's Cay is a short drive from The Cove Eleuthera. You drive down a narrow sandy road. You can easily drive there in a normal car and don't need a SUV or anything like that.
We went in late May, and it was drizzling, so we didn't stay long. However, on a nice day, you could stay the full day and swim out to the small island. There are one or two houses close by, but we saw no one else around.
The view was beautiful and I would definitely recommend checking this beach out!
If you own or manage Gaulding's Cay, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.