We just got back from our first visit to Cat Island (stayed Aug 4 - Aug 12, 2012) and from reading reviews before our trip, I KNEW that visiting Da Smoke Pot was a must on our (very short) To Do List.
I absolutely was NOT disappointed. On our first visit we stopped in pretty late one night while exploring the island, and even though they were closing up they insisted we still come in and have a drink. From the very first visit Julien and everyone was so friendly and welcoming we knew we'd found a great place and that we'd have to visit again and have dinner.
Not only did we go back for dinner once, but twice. The food was so good and the rake & scrape was so much fun! My husband and I shared the cracked conch and the grouper and both were incredibly delicious, so we just had to have the same thing the 2nd time we visited for dinner! The portions were perfect and the sides were just as good as the grouper and conch. After we finished eating dinner, Julian and his crew introduced the 4 of us (another couple staying at our resort joined us for dinner) to Rake & Scrape and even let each of us try our turn at playing.
If you want a night of good food, good drinks, good music, and GREAT company, you MUST visit Da Smoke Pot, just remember to call ahead (we called around noon-ish) and let them know you're coming. We just got home 2 days ago and I can't wait to go back!
If you own or manage Da Smoke Pot, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.