I know this is relatively new and there is not a category for it on Trip Advisor but I highly recommend gelato at the Canella which is part of the gift shoppe. Gelato to die for and very reasonably priced. If we go more than 1 week without a gelato from here we are hurting. Our favorite is salted caramel but there are always many flavors to choose from. You can get it on a cone or in a bowl with a cone wafer cookie. Delightful and you should check it out, again and again. One of these times I will have a scoop of pink grapefruit.
If you own or manage Caneel Bay, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.