We've been to St. John previously and avoided Fatty Crab, due to the menu selections. Didn't seem like our cup of tea. We were encouraged by a friend who raved about his dinner there, so we decided to bite the bullet and give it a shot this time we were on the island. The results were mixed. We ordered 5 menu items to try (all small portions). Loved the fried wahoo sliders! The pork sliders left something to be desired. The pork was a little fatty and the sauce wasn't the best. The salad of local greens was bitter and not what I was looking for. The crab fritters were excellent and the crispy fried potatoes were good. The sauces were different and surprisingly good. The service was above average and the restaurant itself was very clean and nicely decorated. I would recommend a visit, although I don't know if we will return.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.