My wife and I had the pleasure of dining at Fatty Crab tonight, on our honeymoon, and the food and staff were so impressive that we felt like we needed to immediately write a review! We've been on St. John for about 3 nights now, and this is the best meal so far...the menu is perfect for foodies (or people like us who just like to think that we are). The meal was $84 and included 3 cocktails, an appetizer, a second appetizer, a shared main course, and a dessert. We had the Tuna appetizer, the crab fritters (best on the island!), the fatty duck, and the tempura banana dessert w/ a sweetened condensed milk glaze...it was the least expensive and most delicious meal we've had in our 4 days of marriage! I can't give this place enough praise, except to say that we're only on the island for 7 days, and we plan to eat at Fatty Crab twice!
PS: The Recession Special (Beer/whisky/pickle chaser) was a surprisingly outstanding choice.
If you own or manage Fatty Crab, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.