We were kept waiting 45 minutes after our reservation and only seated then because we agreed to be indoors -- kind of defeating the point of going to this restaurant which is all about the view. Despite our expressed desire to have the food moved along given the time we were forced to wait, the service was very slow. At one point, we were finally told our food was being plated, but it didn't show up for another 20 more minutes, and by then was cold. Obviously they had forgotten one of the orders or perhaps all the orders and let them sit. At this price point, this is service was totally unacceptable, and the food, while potentially good, when seved cold, did not come close to making up for the mess. There was no real acknowledgment or acceptance of responsiblity for all the problems and no intent to make even a token effort to compensate us for the spoiled experience and cold but very expensive meal. We heard from a couple who went the next night that they experience and witnessed similar botched service. There are many excellent restaurants on St. John. We liked Tapa and Morgan's Mango particularly. There is no reason to put up with a restraurant run so incompetently and pay and arm a leg for doing so.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.