Maho Beach has been our favorite for quite some time during our visits to St John. However, lots of people have found it now and they've added convenient parking so it's a little more accessible. We visited Maho this time and decided to try Gibney.
We tend to get there early in the morning so the 3 convenient parking spots are generally open. Parking can be a problem and it's a little walk to the beach but this is our new favorite beach. I'd encourage everyone to get there around 9, leaving the prime spot for us!!! It'll be hard to go elsewhere for us. The beach is a little more sloped than Maho but nothing major.
If you own or manage Gibney Beach, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.