This was by far one of worst experiences ever. It almost ruined our honeymoon completely. Foremost the setting was beautiful and our server was nice but the real issue occurred after we left the restaurant. While eating my husband mentioned that the paella had a slightly sour taste. i immediately told him to return it but he' s stubborn and said its probably the spices they cooked it in and it wasn't that bad. Well eating it led to him being sick that night and the whole next day. Thank goodness we were on a 5 day trip or we wouldn't have had any time to enjoy the rest of what St Thomas had to offer. I honestly can't rate this place any higher than poor and thats being nice.
If you own or manage Amalia Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.