Amalia is located on a pathway ("passage") between blocks. The location does not attract the masses of tourists looking for t-shirts. Rick, our waiter, was exceptional. And the food was even better. The fresh fish specialty was heaven, as was the gazpacho soup, with little tiny ice chips on top to keep in cold. Lots of locals were enjoying the restaurant the afternoon we were there. A bottle of well priced wine made the afternoon that much more enjoyable.

Just a short note to say I have been back to Cafe Amalia twice since writing the first review. It is still wonderful and the Salmon with Honey Mustard Glaze is DIVINE!!! I have been going through health so what a treat to have Cafe Amalia there through my journey. Thanks again Maymard & Helga

A pure joy, lamb shank the best I have ever eaten! My wife had the seafood casserole and it was erupting in flavor! Her tomato and crab salad could have been a whole meal! The waitress was overwhelmed with customers, but coped handily. Truely one of the best places on the island to eat for fine dinning. Try the Key Lime pie, also a grand treat!

Our beautiful waitress from Austria was wonderful. The food was fantastic. Maynard is a top notch host. Best place to go in St Thomas...hands down. Coming back again before we leave the island.