While in St. Croix for business, a group of us popped over to Turtle's Deli based on the recommendation of a local. Turtle's Deli has sandwich specials, specialty sandwiches or you can request a sandwich the way you want it. You have a choice of several different kinds of bread (think I recall seeing at least 5 different kinds to choose from) or rolls. The sandwiches are rather large and are served with a quarter spear of a dill pickle. Price-wise, you do pay more for a sandwich than you would in the continental US, but prices were pretty good considering that this was island dining where everything costs more. I would definitely return here as the food was great and the view was sublime! Little tables are set up outside so patrons can enjoy their meals and watch the ocean. Such a calming and relaxing view.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.