We ended up eating at this restaurant three times in our week-long visit. The pizza was actually amazing. I think you come to expect things to just be okay for a vacation meal in an island environment but this was way above expectations. It's right there close to the boardwalk area, open air, and open from lunch to late evening. Nice folks work there, too.
If you own or manage You Are Here, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.