I almost hesitate to give it 5* as more of you will stop by and take up the few valuable tables they have here! Seriously though, the food is nicely presented and tasty. The prices are on-par for STX and probably a better value comparitively. There is A/C in the bar that is actually cool (a rare commodity in STX). As other have written, the freshly cut duck-fat fries are so delicious and generously presented in a bucket.
If you own or manage Tavern 1844, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.