This is a must go for anyone on the island! While it is far from "island food" it is a fantastic meal in a nice, low key setting.
The burgers and duck fat fries were fantastic and the beer selection is the best on the island.
One note, if you're going for one of the lobster dishes call in advance to verify they have. On our visit due to weather they did not... but, a diver sea scallop and brie burger satisfied us perfectly!
If you own or manage Tavern 1844, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.