First, I have to preface this review by saying that I went to Beaches in May of 2005. I'm playing catch-up with my reviews after finding Trip Advisor. I've seen positive reviews lately, so perhaps they've corrected many of the problems I encountered when we went with my then 5 year old daughter.
We chose Beaches because we were looking for an all-inclusive resort that catered to families/kids and was on an island that we could fly to non-stop. Turks and Caicos fit the bill and my wife and I had our honeymoon at Sandals (couples only sister resorts) in St. Lucia, so we thought we made a good choice. I could not have been more wrong.
We had a French Village Luxury Room with a view of the pool. The room was average. Your basic hotel room. There were some instances of cockroaches and ants, but it is the Caribbean and we've come to expect this. The French Village is not close to the beach, so plan accordingly if you want to be closer to the beach.
The staff that we dealt with were, for the most part, friendly. There was the occasional grumpy or indifferent employee, but we've come to expect that not every employee can be expected to be friendly and hospitable all the time. Everyone is entitled to bad days.
Overall, the food was decent, but not great. Some high points, but more low points. The best meal we had was at Sapodilla's which is the adult only restaurant (we got a sitter for that night). Kimono's was horrible. The sushi was mediocre and while the hibachi tables were fun, they doused every course in this horrible terriyaki sauce. We've been to a lot of Japanese restaurants and the best cook the food with a little bit of soy and fresh garlic. There was none of that here. The breakfast buffets at both Giuseppie's and Reflections was standard resort fare (not hard to screw up). Arizona's and Schooners are slightly above average for dinner. Perhaps the view and sunset at Schooners makes the food taste better. Lunch buffet at Arizona's was not bad, nor was dinner at Giuseppie's, but again there was nothing outstanding to speak of. Not even one signature dish in each place. Bobby D's is just plain nasty, but the kids love it. Lots of fried food and bad pizza and hamburgers. The hit of the week was Cafe de Paris. It was close to our room and my wife loves coffee, so she was there during the evening. The pastries and snacks were very good. My daughter loved getting hot chocolate (to emulate my wife with coffee) at all times of the day. A great memory.
With 3 pools on the resort and a nice beach, you would think that it would not feel crowded. Wrong! First, as with cruises, you have to be up at the break of dawn to get a decent seat and sometimes to get a seat at all. People throw towels and books on chairs at probably 6AM to reserve spots. I could deal with this if the people were actually using the chairs throughout the day. There was multiple occasions where the "saved" seats were left unoccupied until later in the afternoon after the people came back from the beach. This practice was also prevalent on the beach. The staff was doing nothing about this. To make matters worse, the pools were closed more than once during the week. There is a no diaper policy for the pools, but parents ignore the warnings anyway and their non-potty trained kids ruin it for everyone when they defecate in the pool. By law, it has to be shocked and shut down for 24 hours. To compound this problem, 2 of the 3 pools (the one in the French Village and the kiddie pool) were shut down at the same time!!! Probably the same kid that did it too. Now the whole resort is crammed on the beach and the pool by Arizona's.
We put my 5 year old in the Kid's Club on the 2nd day and she hated it. She said that the people were always yelling (they weren't even yelling at her, but that upset her nonetheless). After that, she didn't want to go back. I will chalk this up to bad parenting and not put the blame entirely on the people that run the Kid's Club, although they probably could have handled the situations that I witnessed, a little better. That being said, my daughter loved the babysitter she had when we went to dinner for some mommy/daddy time. She told us all the great things she did with her. I wish I could remember her name for the purpose of this review.
Now onto the low point of the week and the main reason we will not return. My wife is fair-skinned and likes to stay out of the sun when possible. On the beach there are a limited amount of thatch huts to provide shade. One day, I stayed by the pool and she took my daughter to the beach. She came back about an hour later crying hysterically and shaking. Apparently, a group of people took their stuff and left the beach hut. Seeing this, my wife made her way over and sat down. After being there for a bit, an elderly man approached her and demanded to know what she was doing in "his" seat. She said the seat was empty and no towels or belongings were there. He became beligerent and said that is impossible and that they had those chairs all week. He then proceeded to pick up her beach bag and throw it a good 10 feet. All of this right in front of my daughter. Understandibly distraught, she got up and took my daughter back to me by the pool. When she told me, I almost lost my cool and was going to go down to confront him, but instead we filed a report with security so that we would not get kicked off the resort for starting a fight. They said they couldn't do much unless they caught him doing it, but we pointed the man out to security and they were going to ensure that they didn't do this to anyone else. As far as we know, they did not confront them about the incident.
Overall, the resort is nice and we could even look past the shortcomings in the food, but what we cannot tolerate is rude and low class guests that ruin the experience for everyone. People that have no respect for the facilities (pool), are rude to the staff, expect their rowdy and uncontrollable kids to be babysat while they go off to the beach, are pushy in lines at the buffet and worst of all, expect that anything on the resort is "theirs" and there for the taking (chairs). I e-mailed the resort after this trip and we never heard back from them. Not even an apology in an e-mail. For the sake of anyone that has gone since then, I can only hope that they took our feedback and made changes. I will never know though since I won't be going back.