We stayed at the Royal West Indies Resort and Jimmy's Dive Bar was one of the few restaurants we could walk to that was somewhat reasonably priced (by island standards). We went for dinner during Happy Hour and learned that only the beers and well drinks applied to the half-off price. Fair enough, but it would have helped if they weren't out of the decent beer, such as the local Turks Head beer. (If you're a Bud Lite or Red Stripe drinker, you'll be fine.) My husband specifically asked for whatever house whiskey was used, plus a dash of 7 Up or ginger ale (i.e., the well drink version of a 7&7). He was charged full price. My mahi mahi was good...or so I thought until I got to my hotel room and had to use the bathroom immediately. (I've had mahi mahi before without incident, so this was not an allergic reaction.) I asked for roasted potatoes for my side but got mashed instead, as they were "out" of roasted potatoes. Not a big deal. My husband really enjoyed the pulled pork sandwich.
So, why not complain about the well drinks we were charged full price for? Because Jimmy's has the right to charge $10 to anyone who whines, causes a fuss, is difficult, etc. I've never seen this "disclaimer" in a restaurant anywhere else. My husband thought it was just a joke, but you never know. I said "Don't complain about the drink price...you find yourself paying $10 more!" We're not cheapskates, but we don't like being taken advantage of either.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.