We enjoyed it. Everyone with our travel group were told to either eat at Marshall's or Serendipity for fine dining. They were the only 2 really good restaurants on the island. We liked this place, Marshall's. Didn't like the chairs: lawn chairs with cushions. Food was very good, but took a long time. Didn't take AMEX. We weren't on the rail so we didn't get a view. Honestly, we dug around and found Spice Mill, which we liked better, then on the last Day we found the best restaurant I've eaten at, (other than Greycliffs in Nassau) called Carambola. So new it isn't even on Trip Advisor yet. Check it out. It has the very best location, ambiance, furniture and setup on a beach I have ever seen. Someone sunk 10 million in this place... Food and wine were great also.