Everything about the Guanahani is amazing. I've stayed there 3 times, and will continue to go every year. Amazing views, relaxing, kind and friendly staff, large grounds to ensure privacy. I love animal life and at sundown u can have turtles come right up to you on your suites property (just have a hibiscus flower ready to feed them). We have always rented a jeep while on the island, u really do need to go out for dinner at night because the islands restaurants are superb. Yes it's pricey, but it's St barths people. Don't believe anything negative you hear about this place, if you don't enjoy yourself there, you might as well kill yourself, you will never be happy.
Oh! One negative, Barto, the dinner restaurant is lame, skip it, there's M&P, Le Ti, and so many other places you should be spending your evenings dining at.