We picked the Eden Rock after a lot of research and we weren't disappointed. Service and atmosphere are top notch. Rooms are clean and relatively spacious. Staff was friendly and breakfast (included in our package) was excellent. Our only concern before going was no pool, which proved to be a non-issue since the ocean was as clear and warm as we've seen. We visited several other hotels (guanahani, toiny) and were very happy with our choice - the central location of Eden Rock is great. No question it's pricey, but excellent stay overall. Favorite dinners included Toiny, K'fe Massai (hands down best value). Also, rent a car - it's a great island to explore. We can't wait to return.