I tried to take some photos of this resort and none of them could come close to capturing the true beauty of the Jamaica Inn. The same goes for writing a review. This place is indescribable. My wife and I spent a week there, and we can't wait to return. It's like we stepped back in time. The elegance, the white table clothes, the decor mixed with the landscaping the beauty of the beach and the wonderful people added up to a memorable experience.
We stayed in room 45, a premier verandah directly on the beach. Every morning we were greeted by breakfast served right on our front porch. We'd spend the days camped out on the beach while Rupert (35 year employee) would serve us drinks, whenever he wasn't busy ruling the croquet court. A waiter would take our food orders and set our table for lunch. There was afternoon tea and a cocktail hour before dinner with proper attire (jacket for men, dress for the ladies) was served. After dinner we'd sit on the terrace have drinks and listen to music. All of this may sound stuffy (croquet, tea, dressing for dinner) but it is not. The Inn has a charm from days gone by. The owner (Peter) and the manager (Mary) made it a point to take an interest in you. The staff was awesome top to bottom. We aren't that adventurous and didn't venture off the grounds, but those who did loved the food at local restaurants and the various activities such as Dunns River Falls.
There is a price that comes with this experience. The Jamaica Inn is not cheap, but it is well worth the money. Your visit will be one that you will never forget. The moonlight couples massage was one of the best things that we have ever done.
If you go, I'd suggest
Get the All-Inclusive Package (meals, drinks and taxes can add up)
Get the Premier Verandah Suite
Get the Couples Moonlight Massage (85 minutes)
Bring cash to tip - although not required, these folks deserve it(far better service than we get in the States) and appreciated it (they appreciate you appreciating them.

Only negatives
It is a haul from the airport (1 1/2 to 2 hours) but the drive is kind of fun.
There is a bit of hierarchy to getting the right beach chairs
BUT all in all it's wonderful

I've reviewed this place before, when we were there 2 years ago. I wouldn't change anything I said before - we love Jamaica Inn and everything was exactly as we remembered/expected. Though it is definitely NOT inexpensive, it is worth it if you are looking for - low key and relaxing in a beautiful resort with wonderful staff all-around.

As long as you know what to expect and it's what you're looking for, I don't see how you can be disappointed here.

1.) Food - Dinners were all five star.
The food was always excellent, it's now even better. No hotel on the island comes close. I could go thru the entire menu.

2.) Staff - Absolutely, positively All-Pro at every position. It is hard to imagine how you can better "share the love"
throughout your entire staff.

The overall positive energy vibe is impossible to underestimate. They are not just capable, not just friendly, but they seem deeply within themselves in peace.

3.) Cleanliness & Service - everything meticulous. The gardens were immaculate.

4.) Work-Out room - I use the bike. It is in perfect condition. The room was always clean and organized.

5.) Coffee - The island has Blue Mountain coffee. It seems others scrimp. Your coffee is spectacular. Please always keep serving your coffee. It is absolutely delicious.

6.) Teddy - at the bar is a master at making people feel good about themselves. He is brilliant.

7.) Mary General Manager - It's impossible to underestimate her Yin-Yang capacity to make sure all is right, yet she presents an otherworldly relaxed Zen peace and sense of open-hearted sharing of life's best.

8.) Peter Morrow - the owner, at the right time of year, can easily be found gently abiding within his welcoming space of quiet joy.

Incredible!! What a trip we had to the Jamaica inn in feb.2013. Mary the GM runs the best inn ever.went their with a group of 8 and did not have one complaint.oh just one.Rufus a employee never let me win at croquet..8 games and lost everyone..not only good at this game but a special person.If your worried that the staff might not be very friendly your wrong.We travel a lot as a group and all of us thought the staff was the most friendly anywhere we've been.We met the owner and he is a hands on type of person.Hiring Mary was the best thing he has ever done for the inn.I asked two employees why Mary is soooo good they said " she is so tough and consistent on us ". Well it shows.A very happy place,happy staff,right price,super rooms,great beach and food that will make you come back...A very happy customer...We will return next year..thanks Mary and staff..