It's worth paying to go to this beach. I stayed in an Air BnB place overlooking this beach and was recommended to go there as I travelled to Jamaica solo (crazy I know) Though I finally felt safe on this beach, I was still approached by many men, some trying to sell drugs or get sex, as everywhere in Jamaica, but I still felt safer here than anywhere else. Expect to pay pretty steep prices for the hire of beach chairs, snorkelling equipment etc, but it was worth it, as the minute I stepped out of the gated beach area, or my hotel, I would be swarmed with men yelling at me for whatever. Jamaica sure was a crazy place, but I highly recommend this perfect little spot for some time to unwind.
If you own or manage Doctor's Cave Beach, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.