We just enjoyed our first - though not last - meal at the Waterlot. If you like historic, romantic restaurants with outstanding food, then you should book a table here. (New Yorkers take note, if you like One if By Land, then you'll love this place.) The Oysters Rockefeller are out of this world. The filet mignon was scrumptious and the mud pie was really sublime. We felt that our meal was well served and perfectly paced - thanks to Vincent's inobtrusive attentiveness. One word of caution, we were hoping that it would be a great vantage point for a sunset. Though it wasn't a terrible place to watch the sun go down, we definitely wouldn't go there for the sunset view per se.
If you own or manage Waterlot Inn Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.