It doesn't get more romantic than Barefoot. If you want to (pretty much) guarantee on the beach seating, make your reservation early in the evening. They know people are there for sunset so no one rushes you anyways. Sunset was absolutely gorgeous, and the wait staff are expert photographers!
The food was just as tasty as the atmosphere was romantic. The scallops app with vanilla bean skewers was so original and great tasting! We both ate fish and thought it was great. I REALLY enjoyed the banana-misu (combined two of my favorite things).
Tip: make reservations right when you arrive. They book up and may be closed if there's a festival in the park next door. Even if you don't go for dinner, stop by for a drink!
Double tip: if you want the romantic sunset but really don't want to eat at the restaurant, all of Aruba's beaches are public. A taxi can drop you off at the park and you can walk along/sit on the beach for sunset. There were several people swimming at dusk while we were there.
If you own or manage Barefoot Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.