We orignially had planned to spend just three days of our week-long vacation staying in and around English Harbour before moving on to the resort areas. However, three days in, we found both the Ocean Inn and the English Harbour area so charming that we stayed there for the duration. English Harbour is a yachting center with a year-round population of British ex-pats living the good life.
The Inn is not for everyone, but a good choice for those who are a little more independent in their travel tastes (fans of all-inclusive resorts should stay elsewhere). It reminded us quite a bit of some of the guest houses you find in the Mediterranean-- quaint little cottages staggered down a steep hillside, all with gorgeous (perhaps the best) views of English Harbour. The grounds are impeccably gardened with a variety of tropical flowers and mangos. The place is overrun by tiny lizards, tree frogs (whose chiping lulled us to sleep each night), and finches--the latter of whom gather to accept hand-fed gifts of toast and cereal over breakfast (included in the price of the room). We paid just $60US/night for our room, making it the best bargain on the island (it should be noted that we were there in the off season, and room rates go up 50% or more from January-April). There are also rooms in a main building, but call or email ahead to request a cottage.
The cottages are simple but clean, with firm beds, AC, cable tv, ceiling fans, etc. We opted to spend an extra $3 US a night to rent a lockbox (although, this was in large part due to the fact that I was secretly towing an engagement ring). Eustace, the proprietor, is an extremely gregarious gentleman who spent many years working for the now-defunct Eastern Airlines. He can make arrangements for taxis, sailing/snorkeling excursions, etc. There is a small, but lovely pool that we took a dip in after dinner each night (daytime being reserved for the beaches), we became engaged. Eustace maintains the Tree Trunk Bar--a nook off the main patio that operates on an honor system. We greatly recommend his pre-mixed rum punches, although recommend adding a floater of Myer's.
The Ocean Inn perhaps makes best sense for those planning to rent a car (which we did via Expedia for less than $200US/week), although it should be noted that driving on the island is not for the faint of heart--even to Bostonians. However, driving does give you a high degree of freedom to go visit Antigua's legendary beaches, and to see what you're not missing at the big beach resorts. Just drive slowly and defensively. We highly recommend driving to Long Bay/Pineapple Beach, and renting chairs from the Long Bay hotel (which along with Ocean Inn is another of the hotels on Antigua's list of "very intimate places").
The $10US fee for chair rental is deducted from the price of a verygood lunch overlooking one of the nicest beaches on the island). Other good beach bets include nearby Galleon (the far end of which has exquisite snorkelling), Half Moon Bay, and Hawksbill.
On Sunday nights, plan to go to Shirley Heights to listen to Calypso & Reggae and dine on barbecue (people take taxis from all over the island to attend, but it just a stone's throw--or $10EC/$3US taxi ride--from English Harbour). Great dining in and around English Harbour. Try: Life (a sailor hangout, and terrific value), HQ (maybe the best restaurant on the whole island), and A Taste of the Caribbean (the homemade ginger beer alone is worth the cost of the whole meal). Admiral's Inn is a great splurge for Barbudan Lobster Thermidor, lamb chops, and their famous rum punch.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.