We booked a 10 day stay through Luxury Link, which placed us in one of the new premium beachfront suites (#19 - on the ground floor) - an excellent location. At first, it appeared that the resort was filled mainly with guests well into their 60s+, but as the week progressed, younger couples appeared as well, some honeymoon, some in their 30s and 40s. Most guests were English, with perhaps 10% Americans.
As a luxury resort, the accommodations were top notch with front row views out of your room directly onto the beach and ocean beyond. The king beds and pillows were firm and comfortable, good lighting for reading sheets, soft, housekeeping consistent - perhaps the towels could do with a bit of upgrading. The daily replenished frig (with beer, soft drinks, juices and bottle water) was a nice addition - although we had to ask the drinks man for ice - it was not automatically refilled. The only other shortfall in the room, was that the flat screen TV did not swivel, so no TV watching from the bed - however, we were pleasantly surprised to receive several premium movie channels (HBO etc.), not that we came for TV watching, but with little to do after dinner, it was nice to catch a movie in the room.
The beach was excellent, and I guess we were blessed with amazing weather, as it was swimable every day except one. There is a drop off, as others have mentioned, but otherwise, the Caribbean was lovely, and enough passing boat traffic to be entertaining.
The restaurants (at this visit) were filled to capacity with sometimes a short wait for a table or service, but since it was high season and fully staffed, the service was pretty good for a Caribbean resort. A third restaurant was due to open by April 1, so that should substantially improve the "full up" restaurants at peak hours.
Meals were good to very good. Breakfast buffets were not as lavish as at some other luxury resorts (i.e. Caneel Bay or Little Dix), but you could order from the menu as well, and dishes came out hot and fresh within 5-10 minutes. We would have preferred buffet lunches as well, but the lunch menu was tasty and varied (although a greater variety of salads would have been welcome), and had a daily set of changing specials. Dinner, too had a nice selection, dishes were generally very good - a few misses,- some very good, but nothing fantastic either. Barbecue buffet on Thursday nights was a hit. We were actually a bit disappointed with the small intimate Gaugin restaurant - very pretty setting, but the Asian influenced menu never changed in the 10 day we were there, and we got bored quickly - everything was pretty much soy based flavors.
As an all inclusive, unlimited cocktails by the glass were always available at the 3 bars, but although the tropical mixed specialties were very tasty, they must have just waved the rum bottle over the top of the glass, because not once did we taste any alcohol - something that definitely could be improved upon (and we are not drinkers- perhaps a cocktail before dinner, or one with lunch). House wines served with meals were very pleasant, usually a choice of 2 or 3of each red, white and rose.
My husband indulged in a few massages that came with our package, and he definitely enjoyed them - so that was a plus. The other standout was the service and attitude of the employess: smiles and friendliness from every single one - adding to a relaxing and delightful vacation escape.
At the end of every stay at a new place, we always ask each other if this was good enough for a return visit, and we both agree - definitely yes. After traveling to at least a dozen Caribbean islands in over 30 years, and staying at more then 20 different resorts, Galley Bay is worthy of a return visit .