We ate here three times during our stay on this beach, and had great meals every time. I had the lamb shanks the first night - if there are lamb shanks on a menu, I HAVE to order them! They were pretty good, thought not the best I've ever had, but I really loved the setting and the atmosphere of the restaurant and my husband had a great meal so we were definitely going to come back. On our next visit I tried the chicken salad which I loved so much I had again on our last night in Rarotonga.
The prices were fairly standard for the Cook Islands, around the average $30 mark for a main, which seems to be what you should budget to spend at most places.
Friendly staff and really nice cocktails, good service and yummy food. Just what you want in a restaurant. Also, the decor was really well done - some places try too hard with their boat themes and get it wrong, but we thought that the Waterline had it just right.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.