We spent one night, 26th April, in CM, and chose the Osteria as the Pizzaria was so unwelcoming.
Because of this we had the best meal of our whole trip, fillet of beef with a mixed salad. Very simple, but so satisfying. The atmosphere was very Tuscan, as a family were there celebrating a daughter's third birthday, and a long table was being prepared for a larger group later in the evening. (Seating for eleven... a football team?) The service was friendly and patient with two Brits who have very little Italian. The place was busy all the time, so is obviously well known despite being located in a small hill village, which is certainly off the Brits tourist route. Worth returning to CM for the Osteria alone.
If you own or manage Osteria del Cavaiolo, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.