Yeah, just based on everything I've read and all of the pictures I've seen, Viceroy looks A LOT more luxurious, updated, modern, well kept than the other resorts that get brought up here. (perhaps that's why they're bankrupt? haha)
I've read that the other resorts are more "Caribbean" and have the culture of the Caribbeans, where Viceroy is more modern and lacks that culture. When I go on vacation, I'd rather be comfortable and living luxuriously so we chose Viceroy for our honeymoon in December.
It all comes down to personal preference. There's pros and cons to each, but if we're talking rooms, decor, upkeep, etc.... then it goes to Viceroy handsdown IMO (and again, this is solely based on secondary research and photographs so take it with a grain of salt obviously)
Edited: 4:40 pm, May 24, 2011