I would suggest you stay at both places. They are so different from each other. Montezuma is good for activities and you can walk to many of them. Santa Teresa has beautiful beaches and a huge selection of accommodation and restaurants. Do all of your 'activities' in Montezuma then head over to Santa Teresa and kick back, relax, watch the sun set and find a place to stay that is central so you don't have to hire any type of transportation, other than to get to Tambor.

Although Montezuma is closer to Tambor, it doesn't cost much more to get from Santa Teresa to Tambor to fly out.

Wow, thank you both!

What would you recommend for a centrally located hotel in ST that isn't too noisy or pricey?

What's the best way to get from Montezuma to ST?

What's the best way to get from ST to Tambor, and how much time should we allow for that?

if you're just doing a day trip, rent an atv, if you're going for a few days, a taxi will do. tambor to st will probably be an hour, the first half on paved road then gravel road over the hills. i've never stayed in st but i recommend amor de mar in montezuma.

I don't know your budget, but you can look at these two sites to get an idea of prices, amenities and locations:

www.nicoyazoom.com/en/hotel-guide/index.html

http://www.nicoyapeninsula.com

The best way to get from Montezuma to Santa Teresa(1/2 hr) and from Santa Teresa to Tambor (30 - 40 minutes) is by cab.

You can catch a local bus that goes from Montezuma to Cobano then get on a connecting bus from Cobano to Santa Teresa if you want to go least expensive and haven't got more than a bag or backpack to carry.

Thank you, wefish, that website is very helpful. We are thinking of staying at Mangos in Montezuma, but aren't yet sure about ST. Our budget is $60-$100 per night. My wife is looking for cleanliness and safety... for me- a quiet night of sleep and a swimming pool! :)

if you stay in the hotel part of los mangos, be sure to stay on the top floor at the end. those wooden floors are noisy!

Looking for a clean, safe hotel with a pool in Santa Teresa? Consider Raratonga Apartments. Really nice staff and excellent location in the northern part of town. Close to a beach where there are few rocks, gorgeous vistas, soft sand, and shade for throwing down a beach towel. I also like Otro Lado. Hope this is helpful!