We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox. Mac: Safari.
Friends who know New York City

Favorites (0)

Connect with friends - see if New York City is one of their favorites.

Can Advise Me (0)

Connect with friends - see if they have advice on New York City.

Been There (0)

Connect with friends - see if they've been to New York City.

Going There (0)

Connect with friends - see if they're going to New York City.

Free Newsletter

Interested in New York City?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for New York City each week.

New York City Forum: Hotel Mela


TripAdvisor™ Best New York City Travel Deals

www.CPManhattanTimesSquare.com New York City Hotel Deals At Crowne Plaza Times Square on Broadway.
www.Expedia.com Get Our Best Price Guarantee on the New Hotel Mela in New York City.
NewYorkCityLuxuryHotels.com Stay at a better hotel than you thought you could afford.

Sign in / Register
 
New York City Forum
New York City Destination Experts
  • Members who are knowledgeable about this destination and volunteer their time to answer travelers' questions.
nywhiz
nywhiz
Posts: 40,373
GreenWhiteBlue
GreenWhiteBlue
Posts: 9,142
New York City experts wanted. Know someone? Tell us.
Crans
Crans
Posts: 9,474
MoreFFmiles
MoreFFmiles
Posts: 2,826
BrooklynMel
BrooklynMel
Posts: 2,232
queensboulevard
queensboulevard
Posts: 18,950
kateoz
kateoz
Posts: 5,041
tmoo6
tmoo6
Posts: 6,104
nyc10025
nyc10025
Posts: 6,656
Hide
Search in: 

Watch This Topic Post a new topicReply to this post
 Pages: 1 2 3  Next>>
   Tim in the Dam
   Joined: Nov 2006
   Forum posts: 2
   Travel map pins: 0 

Posted on: 10:59 am,November 12, 2006
Save Save

Has anyone stayed at the Hotel Mela in New York ?

I'd like a review. I'm looking for a smallish boutique style hotel .. good quality and great service. Willing to pay for it but don't want to spoil a 5 day break with mediocre accomodation.

Anyone got a view?

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   New York
   Joined: Mar 2005
   Forum posts: 5,745
   Travel map pins: 1 

Posted on: 11:13 am,November 12, 2006
Save Save

Alas, there are no reviews because its opening has been postponed (more than once) so no one has yet stayed there

tripadvisor.com/ShowTopic-g60763-i5-k858775-…

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   New York City, New York
   Joined: Sep 2004
   Forum posts: 40,373
   Travel map pins: 130 

Destination Expert  What's this?
for New York City
nywhiz
Posted on: 11:45 am,November 12, 2006
Save Save

....and on photos, rooms look very small to me. The Rockefeller Center hotel is relatively new. The Bryant Park hotel and the Library are other smallish hotels in that area. The Iroquois, the Chambers and City Club are also worth checking.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   New York City
   Joined: Sep 2006
   Forum posts: 20
   Travel map pins: 66 

Posted on: 1:13 pm,November 16, 2006
Save Save

Unfortunately we have been delayed in opening due to construction issues. Our rooms are actually nice and smartly formatted. We have rooms ranging from 157 - 850 sq ft. I invite the local experts on this site to stop by and complete a site inspection.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   Danbury, Connecticut
   Joined: Sep 2004
   Forum posts: 5,320
   Travel map pins: 58 

Voyagereuse
Posted on: 6:15 pm,November 16, 2006
Save Save

David,

Thanks for responding. Can you tell us when the opening is? Also, are you notifying guests that booked reservations that you aren't opening on time? That was a complaint made by some posters on this board...that they either didn't find out in a timely manner or weren't notified at all.

It would be good for us to know what your policy is. Good luck and I hope things are running soon.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   New York City
   Joined: Sep 2006
   Forum posts: 20
   Travel map pins: 66 

Posted on: 2:37 pm,November 17, 2006
Save Save

We have since closed out the year due to the uncertainty of the target date. We are waiting on one last componant which is certification. To answer your question we have contacted as many guests that we could as you must remember people book through various channels such Travelocity, Hotwire etc. We are unable to call these guests directly due to a confidentality agreements.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   USA
   Joined: Jan 2006
   Forum posts: 1,938
   Travel map pins: 5 

Posted on: 3:00 pm,November 17, 2006
Save Save

Well, have you asked Travelocity, Hotwire, Expedia, etc. to help you contact those people?

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   New York City
   Joined: Sep 2006
   Forum posts: 20
   Travel map pins: 66 

Posted on: 3:05 pm,November 17, 2006
Save Save

They are doing their part but it sometimes is difficult for them to contact the guests as it is done via email. First consumers sometimes do not check their personal emails for days at a time. In addition we are compensating guests in various forms from percentage off to complimentary stays depending on each situation. We have had a great response from about 90% of the guests that were suppose to stay with us.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   New York
   Joined: Mar 2005
   Forum posts: 5,745
   Travel map pins: 1 

Posted on: 3:13 pm,November 17, 2006
Save Save

Being the point man amidst unfortunate circumstances beyond your personal control is surely an uneviable position, David. Hope it's soon smooth sailing for guests -- and the staff!!

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   New York City
   Joined: Sep 2006
   Forum posts: 20
   Travel map pins: 66 

Posted on: 3:34 pm,November 17, 2006
Save Save

Thank you so much for the positive comment. You are correct this is no fun and quite delicate. We're in the business to take care of guests and enrich their NYC experience. Unfortunately we are unable to provide these things as this is out of our control (the certification). I do believe however that when we do finally open for business that it will knock the socks off of people. We are not your typical boutique hotel. We are going for comfort of an upscale NY apartment with soothing color schemes, extra comfortable beds, state of the art technology and fantastic guest services.

Our restaurant opens in March which will be vietnamese-french fusion.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate
   UK
   Joined: Aug 2005
   Forum posts: 281
   Travel map pins: 4 

Posted on: 4:07 pm,November 17, 2006
Save Save

I've plenty of respect for you coming onto the forum and explaining what is happening. I'm not sure that many people would have taken that step.

Hopefully people will take you up on the offer to look around.

We are looking forward to our visit next year.

Reply to this post
Report as inappropriate

TripAdvisor™ Best New York City Travel Deals

www.CPManhattanTimesSquare.com New York City Hotel Deals At Crowne Plaza Times Square on Broadway.
www.Expedia.com Get Our Best Price Guarantee on the New Hotel Mela in New York City.
NewYorkCityLuxuryHotels.com Stay at a better hotel than you thought you could afford.