We lucked into finding this place yesterday after a day at Cedar Point. A great alternative option to the multiple chains in this town, this place is a local-feel bar, where we enjoyed the food. I had one of their homemade soups (a soup of the day - Italian wedding soup), which was great. It was a Monday night in May, so it was pretty empty - apparently that is different in the summer, when the boating crowd arrives.
Address is 1319 First Street, Sandusky, OH 44870; 419 627 1964. To get there from Cedar Point, follow the signs to turn right towards the historic Sandusky waterfront (before you reach TGI Fridays on the left) - it is a blue building on the right after a few blocks.