I really like Casa Morada. Not a big fan of the islander. Too busy for me. The three you have are all so different it really depends on what you are looking for.
Islander = big family resort. Cheeca upscale family resort and Casa Morada is small boutique type hotel.
We recently spent time in Islamorada. I heartily recommend Cheeca. Loved it. We looked at the Islander and Case Morada but I'm glad we chose Cheeca.Edited: 8:04 am, May 09, 2013
thanks! i looked at everything again last night and i think we are going to go with Cheeca :) very excited for my trip!!